Case No. A71-2112/2022

Recovery of RUB 1,056,000 for software: a licensing dispute

The licensee did not pay extra for the program and challenged its performance. The court recovered the debt by assessing the contract, the transfer of the product, correspondence and expert opinion.

The result

1,056,000 RUB of debt recovered. Execution of the license agreement is confirmed by a set of documents and technical research.

Why is the debt owed?

The licensor granted an entrepreneur the right to use the Gootax software. Under the contract of 15 October 2020, the package of non-exclusive rights cost RUB 1,500,000. The parties agreed on instalments and later extended the deadline for payment of the balance. A supplementary agreement provided for a software modification.

The payment was incomplete. The licensor filed a claim for recovery 1,056,000 RUB of debtThe dispute was considered by the commercial court of the Udmurt Republic in case No. A71-2112/2022.

Why the dispute did not boil down to an unpaid bill

The licensee challenged the proper performance of the contract and the efficiency of the program. Therefore, for recovery, it was important to confirm not only the amount of debt, but also the compliance of the transferred product with the agreed characteristics.

At the center of the dispute were specific questions: what the parties included in the program, what functions were related to individual improvements, when they provided access for testing and what exactly contained the comments of the licensee.

What evidence mattered

Program description in the contract. The courts matched the product with the agreed Appendix 1. This made it possible to evaluate performance according to established requirements, rather than according to expectations that arose after the conclusion of the contract.

Transmission and testing. The case materials include a letter of 3 March 2021 supplying access codes and documentation, the licensee’s comments of 10 March and the response of 25 March enclosing acceptance certificate No. 15. This correspondence confirmed that the product had been made available for testing.

Content of comments. The courts distinguished the core software product from the “Indriver” modification. Objections concerning that modification were assessed against its scope and agreed terms. The modification under supplementary agreement No. 5 was subsequently delivered under acceptance certificate No. 100 dated 12 October 2021.

Expert opinion. The expert examination dated 20 January 2022, No. 1640/01/22, confirmed that the software complied with the contract; the defects listed in the demand letter were not found. The report was assessed together with the contract, acceptance documents and the parties’ conduct.

Outcome of the proceedings

The court recovered 1,056,000 RUB of debt and 23,560 RUB of expenses for the payment of state duty. The decision was made on January 24, 2023. The appeal decision was issued on April 25, 2023, the decision of the Intellectual Property Court – on August 31, 2023. The result of the recovery remained after the appeal.

Denis Samokhvalov represented the licensor in the appeal and cassation instances. Participation is reflected in the relevant judicial acts.

These amounts are court-ordered claims. Information on the actual receipt of money in this analysis is not given.

What this means for the IT business

The working product and the proof of its transmission are different tasks. The contract, technical description and correspondence should allow you to restore what was promised, what was transmitted and what comments were stated.

  • Separate the basic product and additional work: for each revision, fix the composition, price and acceptance procedure.
  • Save confirmation of transfer of accesses and documentation, test results and responses to comments.
  • Check whether the claims relate to agreed features, a separate module, or new customer wishes.
  • In a technical dispute, determine the subject of research on the contract and the specific arguments of the parties.

The “as is” clause does not in itself exempt from the performance of agreed obligations. In this case, the totality of evidence of conformity and efficiency of the program was important.

If the customer does not pay for the program or improvements

For the first enquiry, it is enough to describe the subject of the contract, the unpaid amount and the nearest term. Then you will need a contract and annexes, acceptance documents, correspondence about the transfer and testing, customer comments and payment information.

I will check the grounds of recovery and objections of the customer, determine the missing evidence, prepare a claim and position for the court. The cost and amount of work are agreed upon after reviewing the documents.

How to reconcile the rights, source and access in the contract with the developer

Recovery of debt from the counterparty

Court decisions in case No. A71-2112/2022

Discuss a Software Dispute

Briefly describe the contract, the amount of claims and the current stage of the dispute.

Discuss the task
Let's discuss your matter

Let’s start with the facts and decide what to do next.

I will first review the circumstances and documents. We will then agree the date, time and format of the consultation.

MAXTelegram
WeChatShow QR codeHide QR code
WeChat QR code for adding patron-ds

Scan the QR code in WeChat to add me to your contacts.

Open the QR code separately

Vadim Sivkov Street, Izhevsk 426008,
189, Building 1, Loft Quarter 212

Look for the office sign «Адвокат ФОКУС Юрист».

Meetings by appointment.

Office locationClick to show the mapClick to hide the map

If the map does not load, use the Directions on Yandex Maps link.

Directions on Yandex Maps

Verification of the site and documents

Send a link to the site and describe the task: launching, updating documents, notifying Roskomnadzor or the request received.

Consultation5 000 ₽

After preliminary review, we agree on the time and format. The volume of preparation of documents and support is determined separately.

Discuss the website and documentsBriefly describe the situation and choose a convenient method of communication. Documents can be transmitted after preliminary acquaintance.