Protection of business · Practical analysis

Protecting honour, dignity and business reputation: facts and opinions

How to distinguish a verifiable statement from an opinion and prepare evidence to protect a citizen or a company’s reputation.

Brief answer

The key question is whether defamatory information about facts that can be verified was disseminated. Disagreement with criticism does not in itself create grounds for refutation.

Statements of fact that can be verified

Article 152 of the Civil Code of the Russian Federation regulates protection against the dissemination of defamatory information. It is necessary to determine the specific phrase, the person to whom it refers, and the context of the publication.

A statement about an event can be tested for validity. A value judgment expresses the attitude of the author. Meaning has the meaning of the statement as a whole, not just a single word.

How to Preserve Evidence

Record the full text, the page address, the date, the author's information and the scope of distribution. Save the correspondence and the responses of the site. For modifiable Internet materials, the appropriate way to provide evidence should be evaluated.

The screenshot should allow you to establish what exactly, where and when is placed. A fragment taken out of context can make it difficult to assess the meaning and affiliation of a statement.

How the burden of proof is allocated

For the application of Article 152 of the Civil Code of the Russian Federation, it is necessary to establish the dissemination of information, their relevance to the plaintiff and defamatory nature. The question of whether statements are true is examined in the light of the distribution of the burden of proof provided for by law.

For example, an allegation of a specific breach of obligation differs from a report of a personal impression of a company’s performance. However, adding the words “in my opinion” does not turn any verifiable charge into a protected assessment. Content and context research is required.

If the meaning of the phrase is controversial, special knowledge may be needed, but the expert does not decide for the court whether the claim is subject to satisfaction. Legal questions about the method of protection and liability remain within the competence of the court.

Which remedies to consider

Depending on the circumstances, refutation, deletion of information and other methods provided for by law are possible. It is necessary to take into account whether the person who disseminated the information is known and where the material is published.

Business reputation is protected for the company. The rules on compensation for moral damage to a citizen cannot be automatically transferred to a legal entity; losses require separate proof.

Balance between protection and freedom of criticism

Resolution No. 3 of the Plenum of the Russian Supreme Court dated 24 February 2005 distinguishes statements of fact from opinions. Constitutional safeguards for freedom of expression are considered alongside the right to protect one’s reputation.

To assess prospects, you need the whole source material, the explanation of the inauthenticity of specific facts, and the consequences of dissemination. Emotional or negative assessment is not the same as reporting a false fact.

The reputation of the company and the position of its head

Publication can refer to a legal entity, a manager, or both. It is necessary to distinguish between whose interests are affected and who claims. The title of a position does not automatically refer to the company itself.

For claims of losses of the company, the confirmed consequences are important: canceled orders, terminated contracts, necessary expenses and a causal connection with the dissemination of information. The decrease in revenue in the same period does not reveal this relationship.

Pre-action enquiry to the author or site can solve the issue faster than the process. In doing so, it is useful to pinpoint the disputed factual statements and required actions, keeping the original publication until it can be modified.

Sources and materials

The conclusions depend on the documents and circumstances of the particular case. The material is not a substitute for individual analysis.

If the question is about your business

Let’s review the documents and establish your position

Tell me what happened, what demands are made and whether there is a deadline for response.

Discuss the situation ↗
Let's discuss your matter

Let’s start with the facts and decide what to do next.

I will first review the circumstances and documents. We will then agree the date, time and format of the consultation.

MAXTelegram
WeChatShow QR codeHide QR code
WeChat QR code for adding patron-ds

Scan the QR code in WeChat to add me to your contacts.

Open the QR code separately

Vadim Sivkov Street, Izhevsk 426008,
189, Building 1, Loft Quarter 212

Look for the office sign «Адвокат ФОКУС Юрист».

Meetings by appointment.

Build a route
Show the mapHide the map

If the map is not loaded, use the “Build a route” button.

Assessment based on the documents

To begin with, it is enough to briefly describe the situation, the amount of claims and the nearest timeframe. If the documents are ready, attach them when you apply.

Consultation5 000 ₽

We agree the time and format after an initial review. Fees and terms for preparing documents and handling the case are agreed separately.

Describe your matter →Briefly describe the situation and choose a convenient method of communication. Documents can be transmitted after preliminary acquaintance.