Breach of contract: what can you claim?

Does the supplier miss the deadline, does the contractor not finish the work, or does the customer evade acceptance? I will check whether it is possible to demand execution, return the advance or recover damages.

Denis Samokhvalov, advocate
Denis SamokhvalovLawyer since 2001 · Izhevsk
I represent business in commercial court all over Russia.

Available claims against the counterparty

Obtain the performance promised under the contract

If the delivery or completion of work is still needed by the business, I will check what the counterparty is obliged to transfer or do when the deadline expires and whether you have fulfilled your counter obligations. I will formulate the requirement so that it can be verified.

Recover the money paid

If the performance has lost meaning for you, I will check the grounds for withdrawing from the contract or its termination. I will check the advance with what you actually received and determine how much you can claim back.

Recover losses caused by the breach

If the breach forced your business to engage another contractor or buy goods at a higher price, I will review those costs and their connection with the breach. I will calculate the contractual penalty and assess which losses can be claimed.

Supplier missed the deadline after receiving an advance

For example, by the delivery date, you received only part of the batch. If the remainder is still needed, we will indicate the underdelivered quantity in the claim and demand the transfer of the goods. If you had to buy a replacement, compare the specifications, prices and terms of both deliveries, check the grounds for returning the balance of the advance and reimbursement of the price difference.

Case No. A56-60561/2025

Two acceptance certificates unsigned: court awards RUB 21.68 million for services

Decision of March 10, 2026. The appeal decision of 7 August 2026.

The contractor provided staff to the customer. For December and January, the customer signed the acceptance documents without comment. In February and March, he received the acceptance documents, but for the three working days stipulated by the contract he did not sign them and did not send motivated objections. There were no objections to the working hours tables either. The courts recognized the provision of services as proven.

The customer asked to set off 7,896,636 RUB of employee meal expenses. Under additional agreements, food was provided by the contractor. The customer did not confirm the agreed rates, payment of food and its issuance to employees. The court rejected an objection to the set-off.

The Commercial Court of St Petersburg and the Leningrad Region awarded RUB 21,684,855.20 in debt, RUB 2,260,036 in penalties, RUB 464,449 in court fees and RUB 200,000 in legal representation costs. I represented the service provider in the Thirteenth Commercial Court of Appeal. The appellate court upheld the judgment.

From a demand letter to the commercial court

Prepare and send a demand letter

I will check the order of notifications and the deadline for response under the law and the contract. I will prepare a claim with a specific requirement, calculation and annexes. We will determine how to send it and how to confirm the content of the shipment and the date of shipment.

Details on the claim work

Record the agreement reached

If the counterparty offers a new term, replacement of goods or refund of money in parts, I will prepare an agreement. We will specify what and by what date he is obliged to fulfill, how the acceptance is fixed and what requirements remain in case of a new violation.

Bring a court claim

If the agreement is not possible, I will prepare a lawsuit and evidence for each claim. You can only charge the preparation of the claim or conduct the case before the court decision. We will agree on the workload and court costs in advance.

Where to start

Describe what the counterparty promised when the deadline came and what you want to receive now. If you have already submitted a claim, state the date and report what the other party responded.

Describe the situation

What documents will be useful

  • Contract, order, specification or estimate.
  • Invoices, payment orders, invoices and acts.
  • Correspondence about deadlines, defects or acceptance.
  • Claim and response, documents on additional expenses.

Documents can be handed over after the first application.

Let's discuss your matter

We'll discuss breach of contract.

I will first review the circumstances and documents. We will then agree the date, time and format of the consultation.

MAXTelegram
WeChatShow QR codeHide QR code
WeChat QR code for adding patron-ds

Scan the QR code in WeChat to add me to your contacts.

Open the QR code separately

Vadim Sivkov Street, Izhevsk 426008,
189, Building 1, Loft Quarter 212

Look for the office sign «Адвокат ФОКУС Юрист».

Meetings by appointment.

Office locationClick to show the mapClick to hide the map

If the map does not load, use the Directions on Yandex Maps link.

Directions on Yandex Maps

Initial enquiry

For your initial enquiry, briefly describe the situation and the nearest deadline. After reviewing it, I will explain which documents are needed and how to provide them.

Consultation5 000 ₽

We agree the time and format after an initial review. Fees and terms for preparing documents and handling the case are agreed separately.

Discuss the breach of contract