The contractor provided staff to the customer. For December and January, the customer signed the acceptance documents without comment. In February and March, he received the acceptance documents, but for the three working days stipulated by the contract he did not sign them and did not send motivated objections. There were no objections to the working hours tables either. The courts recognized the provision of services as proven.
The customer asked to set off 7,896,636 RUB of employee meal expenses. Under additional agreements, food was provided by the contractor. The customer did not confirm the agreed rates, payment of food and its issuance to employees. The court rejected an objection to the set-off.
The Commercial Court of St Petersburg and the Leningrad Region awarded RUB 21,684,855.20 in debt, RUB 2,260,036 in penalties, RUB 464,449 in court fees and RUB 200,000 in legal representation costs. I represented the service provider in the Thirteenth Commercial Court of Appeal. The appellate court upheld the judgment.